This is a collaborative project that anyone who is interested can help work on.
I started us off by reading as many relevant threads as I could find, both here on DarkSpyro and on the Skylanders.proboards forums, to create an incomplete and probably inaccurate 5-tier rankings list to start us off: You lot helped with the rest. We are now in the process of researching, discussing and arguing our reasons for characters being moved up/down tiers until we get things just right.
There is an entirely separate version of the list for the Wii because of the statistical differences there. Different upgrade paths for each character, as well as the Legendary variants, are being considered as separate entities on the list.
This thread is only for PvP rankings for now, but perhaps we could make Single Player orientated tier lists later on if people want them?
Other Important stuff to know:
- At the moment we are mostly concerned with PvP here, not single player! Please remember this while posting.
- Please take in to account whether you use the Wii version or not before posting. This is important!
- The characters in each tier are listed in no particular order… for now? At a later date we could try to number them in order of ability if people feel up to the task.
- Try to avoid Arena Hazards, Items and Food when testing character match-ups to compile tier lists with.
- Do not make “Power of the Skylander depends on the person using it, different people have different play styles, etc” comments here. The reason why you shouldn't do this is in the disclaimer below.
- I still haven’t decided what we’ll do about heroic challenges. I was thinking we could do our best to compose a generalised tier list that assumes all characters have completed an equal amount of heroic challenges in any given match-up. If we come across a character that benefits from heroic challenges so much more/less than others to the point that it changes their tier, we might have to make a separate entry for that character with all heroic challenges completed and that character with none. If there are enough of these extreme differences then we may have to make entirely separate lists for characters that have completed all heroic challenges and characters that have completed none.
- A similar thing goes for arenas: We’ll try to make a generalised tier list that assumes no particular arena is being used in any given match-up.
EDIT: Nibelilt also made a nice little thread with a few other pointers that some people here keep missing: //forum.darkspyro.net/spyro/viewposts.php?topic=60463
BIG FINAL DISCLAIMER: Of course, these tier lists, as with any tier list for any game, are only meant to be taken as guidelines for the purely objective ability of each Skylander in an imaginary situation where the two opponents are of equal skill. In a real life situation, different people have different skills, strategies and play styles, so you should always remember that its these factors that ultimately decide the effectiveness of each Skylander you use. You should go by your personal play styles and use the Skylanders you like instead of going by everything on these tier lists!
---
The Tier Lists (Work in Progress!)
Xbox360 / PS3 / PC Tier List
S Tier - (Overpowered+broken characters)
Stealth Elf / Pook Blade Saint
Zook / Floral Defender
Terrafin / Sandhog
Dino-Rang / Grand Boomerang Master
Drobot / Master Blaster
Cynder / Nether Wielder
Ignitor / Soul of the Flame
Upper A Tier - (Very Good characters that aren't quite S-Tier)
Voodood / Marauder
Double Trouble / Channeler
Camo / Melon Master
Camo / Vine Virtuoso
Bash / Granite Dragon
Bash / Pulver Dragon
L-Bash / Granite Dragon
L-Bash / Pulver Dragon
Terrafin / Brawler
Slam Bam / Blizzard Brawler
Wham-Shell / Captain Crustacean
Sunburn / Flame Lord
Lower A Tier - (Good Characters)
Double Trouble / Conjurer
Cynder / Shadow Dancer
Hex / Bone Crafter
Prism Break / Crystaleer
Sonic Boom / Medea Griffin
Drobot / Clockwork Dragon
Upper B Tier - (Average Characters)
Spyro / Sheep Burner
Spyro / Blitz Spyro
L-Spyro / Sheep Burner
L-Spyro / Blitz Spyro
Voodood / Elementalist
Wrecking Ball / Ultimate Spinner
Sonic Boom / Siren Griffin
Stump Smash / Nut Crafter
Stealth Elf / Forest Ninja
Zook / Artilleryman
Boomer / Demolition troll
Drill Sergeant / Megadozer
Gill Grunt / Water Weaver
Zap / Slime Serpent
Eruptor / Volcanoer
Flameslinger / Marksman
Flameslinger / Pyromancer
Sunburn / Blaze Dragon
Whirlwind / Tempest Dragon
Lightning Rod / Lightning Lord
Warnado / Eye of the Storm
Prism Break / Prismancer
Dino-Rang / Earthen Avenger
Hex / Shade Master
Ghost Roaster / Fear Eater
Ghost Roaster / Skull Master
Chop Chop / Vampiric Warrior
L-Chop Chop / Vampiric Warrior
Lower B Tier - (Below-Average Characters)
Whirlwind / Ultimate Rainbower
Slam Bam / Glacier Yeti
Zap / Tesla Dragon
Chop Chop / Undead Defender
L-Chop Chop / Undead Defender
Trigger Happy / Golden Money Bags
L-Trigger happy / Golden Money Bags
C Tier - (Bad Characters)
Wrecking Ball / Total Tongue
Gill Grunt / Harpooner
Wham-Shell / Commander Crab
Stump Smash / Smash ’n Bash
Boomer / Clobber Troll
Trigger Happy / Golden Frenzy
L-Trigger Happy / Golden Frenzy
Drill Sergeant / Battledozer
Eruptor / Magmantor
Ignitor / Blademaster
Warnado / Wind Master
Lightning Rod / Typhoon Titan
Wii Tier List
S Tier - (Overpowered+broken characters)
Stealth Elf / Pook Blade Saint
Zook / Floral Defender
Terrafin / Sandhog
Dino-Rang / Grand Boomerang Master
Drobot / Master Blaster
Cynder / Shadow Dancer
Double Trouble / Channeler
Ignitor / Soul of the Flame
Upper A Tier - (Very Good characters that aren't quite S-Tier)
Voodood / Marauder
Camo / Melon Master
Camo / Vine Virtuoso
Bash / Granite Dragon
Bash / Pulver Dragon
L-Bash / Granite Dragon
L-Bash / Pulver Dragon
Terrafin / Brawler
Cynder / Nether Wielder
Eruptor / Volcanoer
Sunburn / Flame Lord
Slam Bam / Blizzard Brawler
Wham-Shell / Captain Crustacean
Lower A Tier - (Good Characters)
Double Trouble / Conjurer
Hex / Bone Crafter
Prism Break / Crystaleer
Sonic Boom / Medea Griffin
Drobot / Clockwork Dragon
Upper B Tier - (Average Characters)
Spyro / Sheep Burner
Spyro / Blitz Spyro
L-Spyro / Sheep Burner
L-Spyro / Blitz Spyro
Voodood / Elementalist
Wrecking Ball / Ultimate Spinner
Sonic Boom / Siren Griffin
Stump Smash / Nut Crafter
Stealth Elf / Forest Ninja
Zook / Artilleryman
Boomer / Demolition troll
Gill Grunt / Water Weaver
Zap / Slime Serpent
Whirlwind / Tempest Dragon
Lightning Rod / Lightning Lord
Warnado / Eye of the Storm
Flameslinger / Marksman
Flameslinger / Pyromancer
Sunburn / Blaze Dragon
Prism Break / Prismancer
Dino-Rang / Earthen Avenger
Hex / Shade Master
Ghost Roaster / Fear Eater
Ghost Roaster / Skull Master
Chop Chop / Vampiric Warrior
L-Chop Chop / Vampiric Warrior
Lower B tier - (Below-Average Characters)
Whirlwind / Ultimate Rainbower
Slam Bam / Glacier Yeti
Zap / Tesla Dragon
Drill Sergeant / Megadozer
Trigger Happy / Golden Money Bags
L-Trigger happy / Golden Money Bags
Chop Chop / Undead Defender
L-Chop Chop / Undead Defender
C Tier - (Bad Characters)
Wrecking Ball / Total Tongue
Gill Grunt / Harpooner
Wham-Shell / Commander Crab
Stump Smash / Smash ’n Bash
Boomer / Clobber Troll
Trigger Happy / Golden Frenzy
L-Trigger Happy / Golden Frenzy
Drill Sergeant / Battledozer
Eruptor / Magmantor
Ignitor / Blademaster
Warnado / Wind Master
Lightning Rod / Typhoon Titan