Whoo boy,let's see.
Pros:
-Graphics. As I said several times already,graphics don't make the game,but that isn't going to stop
certain people that gush over them regardless of the game's content and like to put it on a pedestal,and hey,the more fans the series gets,the better.
-Hex's Lightcore dress can't be laughed at now.I won't go into details since this is a Skylanders thread.
-Bosses on Adventure Packs. If I actually wanted the game,for once I'd probably go more after extra levels than characters.As great as levels like Darklight Crypt and Dragon's Peak were,the fact all of them built up to awesome fights that didn't ever happen(except Empire of Ice,which didn't have any buildup) makes them feel like you didn't really do anything but get new hats - like you just went for a trip,not saved villages/species/a kingdom.Now,you actually fight someone in the end,and it makes the APacks all the more worth it.
-By now,haters of the game can't get the upper hand using arguments that could stop some people. Well,if anyone was against a Diablo-lite,now it has the graphics and the jumping to push itself into an almost half-plataformer half-RPG.
Cons: BRACE FOR IMPACT.
-
Needless hype for the game.Yes,it's about the fandom,but I've heard too much of 'this is like SSA,best game ever!','graphics are good,it's superior to all others','doesn't have Giants' hub,Giant sucks despite being SSA and improved' and mostly that the story is good.It's almost like Swap Force is the DOTD of the Skylanders series,and hopefully the way everyone seems to sneer at Giants when last year we all loved it will end soon.
-
Not fixing the lip synching yet focusing on faces.One of the most obvious complaints from SSA and Giants are that the charaters just repeat speaking motions very quickly outside cutscenes. Instead of fixing it with the Beenox engine since they use it for cutscenes too,they proceed to make the motions even more repetitive,slower and put the camera pointing right at them. At least before it was so fast and hard to notice you could forget about it.Which takes us to...
-
Breaking what's fixed.Skipping dialogue was slow in SSA.In Giants,you could skip entire sections with no problems. Now you have little to no way of skipping them,and the stuff I mentioned above to make you even angrier. Other thing that was almost starting to get perfect was the balancing - they made Chop Chop usable,some characters horribly OP were nerfed just slightly as other characters were given ways of getting a bit better. Now we have just HALF of a character that can get revived 3 times and the other half that can steal health,characters that play exactly like some old ones,and stats that surpass the average Giant.One could say the polished-but-small Dread-yacht wasn't good enough of a hub level and Woodburrow fixed it,but that's the exception and not the rule,unfortunately.
-
Plot Holes.Portal of Power and Skylanders lore,Core of Light,Kaos' mom anything,old characters losing their importance immediately as obviously cooler characters take over.I get it takes place in somewhere far away from the Citadel,that it's a new group of developers.But no,
you're doing it wrong.If you need to push away stuff that was stablished before to write(when it's not bad to begin with,of course),your story is NOT good.
-
Character design.I insisted on this for several threads already.Probably everyone thinks it's cool because of the archetypes and not because of the effort put on it,so I'd be just throwing words at the wind by now.
-
Overall laziness.Aside from the 'breaking what's fixed' I said before,the game itself feels like they worked on many points until there was no more perfecting it (graphics,swapping,etc) then rushed others.Some things could be the lack of time to work on,but things like the music shouldn't.Mesmerelda's battle phase theme is EXACTLY 19 SECONDS,looping over and over again(Fire Viper's themes have no more than 26,and that's because I counted little notes that are added between loops).That's not how you OST after great songs we had in this game and the previous ones.
And behold,awesome upgrade pictures that they totally worked on for more than 30 minutes:
I seriously wish I loved this game,but after a while I just couldn't let any of this pass.Sorry guys.
EDIT:I keep forgetting some fandom terms,whoops.