For me, I thought Sonic 06 was the only truly bad game in the "downhill" period. The res of the console ones were at least decent, but got a lot of critisisim. They picked up with Unleashed though, and now Sonic is well and good again.
On the critcical side of things, Soyro is fine. LoS got decent ratings on average. The fanbase is torn though.
Sonic was downhill for a while if you ask me, starting with Shadow the Hedgehog and ending with Sonic 4, where Rush and Secret Rings were the only truely good games. Unleashed screwed up with the werehog stages, Rivals was decent at best, Sonic 06 was terrible, Black Knight was just as bad, and while the first Riders was decent, Zero Gravity sucked.
The fanbase is torn, and it's up to us (whom like both) to pull it back together.
Quote: Wylrin
I never really care what scores games or movies get, because, as I have mentioned before, I am me, no one else can judge something for me. I never look at ratings for games or movies, but when I do, it seems like it's always the exact opposite of what I thought of it. I think I've watched a movie that was like two stars but I thought it was really good.
Exactly. The critic's opinion is good and all, but in the end it's up to what you think.
Take Big Daddy for example. It has a 41 on Metacritic, but I thought it was funny as hell.