Holy crap, I have never seen a moderation team with such low understanding on how to moderate a forum. There are many topics that deserve to be closed while there are many topics ending with Beavcoon or Troll Slug constantly being closed. I didn't really see WHY they should be closed, especially in S&N. There are many more that are similar to those topics. The rest of the moderation team (primarily talking about S&N here) don't do their jobs. The posts that people get away here are absolutely ridiculous, and at any other message board the user would be warned, suspended, or banned.
Anyways, Waka stepped down, right? That's understandable. She is still a moderater though, and dark should probably take the time to demote her if that is her wish. The only time, the ONLY time I have seen JCW do anything in his power is threaten to close a topic about windumup's girlfriend. HIR is alright...but...
Hell, I don't know if it was HIR or some other hunter, but only a month ago they realized they could edit/move their post. Holy hell, thats late.
I'm not ripping on their personalities or trying to create a flame war, but I have never seen a moderation team this lacking. This place is a dump because of it. I'm legitimately surprised I wasn't banned a long time ago too, considering all I would post is random bullcrap. I literally only have two moderated messages.
This topic is not meant to hurt the feelings of the staff, but hopefully to improve their ability.
Just my two cents. Feel free to disagree with me, but please have a reason why.
darkSpyro - Spyro and Skylanders Forum > Stuff and Nonsense > [OPINION] Why do the mods here suck at their job?
zer0dch Ripto Gems: 1916 |
#1 Posted: 16:47:28 16/08/2014 | Topic Creator
|
Edited 1 time - Last edited at 16:48:43 16/08/2014 by zer0dch
|
awesomerockets
Emerald Sparx
![]() |
#2 Posted: 17:04:51 16/08/2014
I remember during the whole Ripto Clan thing, when I tried to claim a topic, I got a moderated message. That's totally fine, I should have, it was spam. The only problem was that practically everyone else who tried to claim a topic did not receive a moderated message. I don't know the whole story here, though. I'm not sure who removed my post or if anyone else got a moderated message, but it kinda bothers me.
![]()
---
go to my guestbook now and sign a petition to get Freddie benson into smash |
zer0dch Ripto Gems: 1916 |
#3 Posted: 17:10:55 16/08/2014 | Topic Creator
Quote: awesomerockets
I have also noticed mods here tend to have a friendly bias against some members. Sorry to hear about that. That's legit bullcrap. Although, the ripto clan mess should have been one big topic. There were like five of them, and it was ridiculous. |
CAV
Platinum Sparx
![]() |
#4 Posted: 17:18:06 16/08/2014
I don't like the mods, but I feel like I should just say that not only has JCW done more than what you claim, but I think JCW carries most of the weight of moderating S&N, and therefore appears as the best mod on the team to me.
That being said most of the team is lacking and from day one it felt like Dark threw darts at the wall with our pictures on it to see who gets in. |
somePerson
Diamond Sparx
![]() |
#5 Posted: 17:20:05 16/08/2014
Most spam here is kept unless it's my spam.
|
DummyZ Gold Sparx Gems: 2844 |
#6 Posted: 17:27:17 16/08/2014
I really don't have much of a thing to say about the situation, but it's pretty clear and pretty obvious that the activity is getting worse day by day.
|
CountMoneyBone
Platinum Sparx
![]() |
#7 Posted: 17:28:22 16/08/2014
here is an advice, if you wan t to be taken serious. dont post in 'Stuff and Nonsense'.....
---
Ha! HA, sage ich. |
Blackholes_Wolf Ripto Gems: 10760 |
#8 Posted: 17:39:16 16/08/2014
who are they again?????
|
zer0dch Ripto Gems: 1916 |
#9 Posted: 17:42:39 16/08/2014 | Topic Creator
Quote: CountMoneyBone
No kidding dude, but did you bother to read the first post? The mods don't carry their weight here. |
Edited 1 time - Last edited at 17:43:01 16/08/2014 by zer0dch
|
Mrmorrises
Platinum Sparx
![]() |
#10 Posted: 17:46:07 16/08/2014
Quote: zer0dch
This is pretty much their biggest problem if you ask me. Some mods don't care if one of their friends is being a total douche. |
somePerson
Diamond Sparx
![]() |
#11 Posted: 17:49:04 16/08/2014
Quote: Mrmorrises
Or most users in general. |
zer0dch Ripto Gems: 1916 |
#12 Posted: 17:52:10 16/08/2014 | Topic Creator
Quote: Mrmorrises
Yup, and its total crap. The mods need to step their game up. This site has some piss poor moderators. |
CommanderGame
Emerald Sparx
![]() |
#13 Posted: 18:39:16 16/08/2014
Problem is, darkSpyro is pretty much a big circlejerk.
|
Samius
Hunter
![]() |
#14 Posted: 18:46:24 16/08/2014
Quote: Mrmorrises
I agree completely. I remember a user getting threatened with suspension just because he/she blurted out that Waka "used to be a guy".. ..And when a mob of people all start insulting a "homophobe" it's a-ok. |
uttster13
Gold Sparx
![]() |
#15 Posted: 19:30:25 16/08/2014
For some reason, I feel like the mods hate me. Is it just me, or does anyone else feel that too?
---
A story. |
Mrmorrises
Platinum Sparx
![]() |
#16 Posted: 19:40:13 16/08/2014
Quote: Samius
If the "homophobe" you're referring to is who I'm thinking of, then the "homophobe" was kinda acting up themselves, from what I remember. Also, people need to know a homophobe is not one who opposes same sex marriage, a homophobe is one who actually dislikes people solely for being homosexual. But yeah, some mods are simply poor at looking at things objectively. |
Edited 1 time - Last edited at 19:42:26 16/08/2014 by Mrmorrises
|
Epic popthorn
Emerald Sparx
![]() |
#17 Posted: 20:03:37 16/08/2014
Quote: uttster13
I think theres 2 or 3 that don't like me, I've never really done anything wong, except defend myself from one of them. |
Spyroboy
Prismatic Sparx
![]() |
#18 Posted: 20:12:53 16/08/2014
I agree completely.
---
「恋愛なんてだっさー‼ヤングは迷わずテクノブレイク一択でしょ‼」 |
zer0dch Ripto Gems: 1916 |
#19 Posted: 20:18:52 16/08/2014 | Topic Creator
Quote: Sesshomaru75
not really an appropriate gif considering the ammount of responses given that every user here agrees. It's topics like "skylanders fan club x" gets made. I remember when we literally had like five of them, like what the hell? |
Metallo
Platinum Sparx
![]() |
#20 Posted: 20:18:56 16/08/2014
Quote: Sesshomaru75
I don't think I've ever seen SpyroD do anything whatsoever. Gill is too young & childlike, IMO. Matteo is probably the worst, I think he abuses his power sometimes. JCW & HIR are the best, they actually do their jobs right without being asses. |
Edited 1 time - Last edited at 20:21:26 16/08/2014 by Metallo
|
zer0dch Ripto Gems: 1916 |
#21 Posted: 20:40:40 16/08/2014 | Topic Creator
Quote: Sesshomaru75
Hey, looks like a cotender for why this forum has become such a piece of crap. How old is Matteo? One of the mods here was 14, and that's really pushing it. |
Mrmorrises
Platinum Sparx
![]() |
#22 Posted: 20:42:22 16/08/2014
Quote: zer0dch
I think he's 15. |
Epic popthorn
Emerald Sparx
![]() |
#23 Posted: 20:51:48 16/08/2014
Quote: Metallo
This. |
zer0dch Ripto Gems: 1916 |
#24 Posted: 20:52:17 16/08/2014 | Topic Creator
Quote: Sesshomaru75
I've been posting here since 2007. The forum actually used to be a nice small community. The gif you posted was unneccesary, and your response back to my claim was a flamable offense. I'm not trying to get you upset, but I just think it was really lame of you to post the gif "just because" in a topic where users are already complaining of this forum being a dump. |
somePerson
Diamond Sparx
![]() |
#25 Posted: 20:57:02 16/08/2014
It scares me when a mod's signature is considered spam and has an alt that he uses.
|
AvatariDragon
Platinum Sparx
![]() |
#26 Posted: 21:06:49 16/08/2014
Mods are people, too.
To be honest, I don't really care about the whole mod thing anyway. With them, if the job is done well and by y'all's standards it's not, the site will run smoothly overall, so no worries there. Without them, the site goes back to the way it was before we had them. I mean, we've only had mods for what, about three years now? Something like that... the point is, we haven't had them for a very long time. However, I still stand by what I said before about how new mods need to be chosen every so often. Anyway, according to what you guys are saying, with or without them, the site is crap, so it makes no difference to me whether we have them or not. |
Edited 1 time - Last edited at 21:08:41 16/08/2014 by AvatariDragon
|
zer0dch Ripto Gems: 1916 |
#27 Posted: 21:07:25 16/08/2014 | Topic Creator
Quote: somePerson
Oddly enough, one part of the reasoning for getting banned was having an alt account. dark52 reminded me before that alts are okay (way long ago...), if they only use that account. Sadly I don't have the PM anymore. --- Quote: Sesshomaru75
You registered in 2012, didn't you? My first acccount here was registered here in April of 2007. And no, that's where you're wrong. You chose to pick a bone with me because I responded to your gif with a legitimate complaint, and you responded with a rude response. I don't have a bone to pick with you, but you're contradicting yourself. edit: As for the topic, I've said enough I can. The mods here are crap at their job. Unless I can find the post where HIR discovered he actually had a mod ability or similar, I don't have much more to say. |
Edited 3 times - Last edited at 21:13:33 16/08/2014 by zer0dch
|
uttster13
Gold Sparx
![]() |
#28 Posted: 21:19:41 16/08/2014
This is how my mommy and daddy used to fight.
![]()
---
A story. |
zer0dch Ripto Gems: 1916 |
#29 Posted: 21:28:41 16/08/2014 | Topic Creator
Quote: Sesshomaru75
You're coming off way more aggressive than you should be, honestly. Quote:
I honestly don't get why you even said this, how long have you been on here? Also, unneccesary comment one. Quote:
Look above at your post history. You're taking way more offense than I am, IMO. I'm just trying to comprehend why you're calling me out, when you yourself are provoking me. Quote:
Once again, post history. I think I gave you a good enough reason. Contradicting may have not been the right word of choice, my apologies. Although, you're making the situation far worse than it should be. One of the reasons I think this forum is such a dump now is because people with attitudes or tone in their posts like yours (not trying to start a war, using your posts for an example) get away with it. The mods don't care, as long as they are their friend. Edit: No need to read my argument with the other user here anymore, we're cool. Back on topic: Maybe I should have posted this in site suggestions? dark may have read it if I posted it there...but I'm a click away of making a topic directed to him, about him. It's complete crap that he doesn't do anything to moderate the site, besides post updates. If he's busy working a full time job, then I understand. Although, he should consider getting a staff that would actually do their job. |
Edited 2 times - Last edited at 21:33:31 16/08/2014 by zer0dch
|
sonicbrawler182
Platinum Sparx
![]() |
#30 Posted: 21:40:08 16/08/2014
I'm kind of uncomfortable with the idea of talking about mods like this out in the open, and grouping them altogether, while simultaneously pointing fingers at a select few.
If people have problems/criticisms regarding certain mods, you're best off going to them directly as individuals, and giving them criticism, even if you do this in public in reaction to something they do, by quoting their post in the topic in question. I did this on another forum when I had a problem with a mod who not only was displaying double standards on what he considers a spam topic, but I also called out how he had a genuinely vile attitude at times and may have been egotistical too, and just made the place hard to enjoy and filled the top topics with negativity and bad language for the sake of it, which could potentially turn people off from joining the site. He's improved since, though, and I actually have some friendly conversations on the boards with him, on occasion. He still sometimes lets his attitude get the better of him and will make brash statements, but it's a lot better than what he used to be like. I guess he's just naturally a bit outspoken and cocky. Likewise, if you think a moderator is doing their job particularly well, throw them a bone and give them credit. This is again, something I have done elsewhere, and it tends to mean a lot, as being a moderator can really, really stress people out and getting told you're bad at you're job without being given very specific and valid reasoning can bring a mod down.
---
"My memories will be part of the sky." |
LegoLander
Yellow Sparx
![]() |
#31 Posted: 23:03:53 16/08/2014
---
The person who finally changed his Christmas avatar. Give me a cookie. |
uttster13
Gold Sparx
![]() |
#32 Posted: 23:05:33 16/08/2014
---
A story. |
xXBeavcoonXx
Gold Sparx
![]() |
#33 Posted: 23:07:38 16/08/2014
Quote: zer0dch
You only hate me because I'm beautiful.
---
now its time to get funky |
LegoLander
Yellow Sparx
![]() |
#34 Posted: 23:24:27 16/08/2014
Quote: uttster13
Ah, sorry. I try to suppress my past as much as possible :/
---
The person who finally changed his Christmas avatar. Give me a cookie. |
ReshiramForever
Platinum Sparx
![]() |
#35 Posted: 23:28:41 16/08/2014
Quote: zer0dch
being for here for a long time is no reason to act like a self-righteous cock
---
self professed austGAYlian |
Mrmorrises
Platinum Sparx
![]() |
#36 Posted: 23:33:35 16/08/2014
Quote: ReshiramForever
He's not even doing that. He's just reminiscing over how he claims the site once was. |
LegoLander
Yellow Sparx
![]() |
#37 Posted: 23:36:05 16/08/2014
Quote: ReshiramForever
![]() Oh yes.
---
The person who finally changed his Christmas avatar. Give me a cookie. |
cowpowa23
Emerald Sparx
![]() |
#38 Posted: 23:38:54 16/08/2014
It's S&N.
I don't think the mods are doing anything wrong with their jobs..^.^
---
I am a Cow. "Moo". |
Seiki
Platinum Sparx
![]() |
#39 Posted: 23:55:06 16/08/2014
Though I wasn't here when the applications were done and promotions were made, I have noticed that some seem to be odd choices and have noticed some that I feel would've been better suited for the job. (No offense to the current staff) Not all of them suck as the topic title implies, and definitely not all in S&N. -JCW can sometimes let his emotions get to him and make rash decisions, though he is still an active part of the moderation team and will act when need be. -HIR sometimes seems to be a little to hesitant to act at times though will still keep order and give friendly warnings when needed. Though he has a been a bit less active as of late due to irl responsibilities, he and JCW are still on the better end of the spectrum and rather good moderators. -Bionicle also seems like a rather good mod. Though I don't see him often outside of the Skylander sections, considering he was the most active in there until Matteo was added to those sections and how despite how chaotic it can be over there, some sense of order still seemed to be established which I congratulate him for running things practically on his own for this time. -Speaking of Matteo, he seems like a good guy, but makes some mistakes when moderating. Mistakes that he will repeatedly make. I see some sense of potential in him to be a good moderator, specifically over the Skylander sections as this seems to be his main interest on the site and rather where he belongs, though he needs to learn from his mistakes and try to handle things more from a third-party viewpoint thinking of the community as opposed to letting his personal feelings get in the way. -While I haven't seen Wild do a whole lot as a moderator, Wild still seems like a good person and I feel is rather good at the position. While I believe having mentioned before about not knowing a lot about role-playing I know Wild still tries to do good and keep a sense of order there by making guidelines for role-playing. A good one in my book. -As for SpyroD, I thought he was some myth that left long before my time until I saw him post an RP once. Honestly, just seems kinda... there, though barely at that. His inactivity is understandable considering I've heard he's in the military, but still, he seems so inactive that the position should rather be passed on to someone who could actually do the job. Haven't seen much of GilGrunt to form too much of an opinion of him, probably not a good thing. With ItsJustMe gone and Waka leaving, I won't go into detail about them. If anyone else isn't listed, that probably isn't a good sign as I don't know of them. It's been mentioned above in this topic that there was been some favortism in regards to how moderation is handled. Something I will agree to seeing, especially in S&N. A lot of **** posts and spam will simply fly by while certain users seem to have to be a bit more careful as to what they post as the moderators are more easy to jump on them. Of course I understand some people may stand out more than others, but in the end some people should have a lot more MMs than I'm betting they do while I have a feeling some get a new MM every day over the simplest of things that probably shouldn't even be getting MM'd. As for the aforementioned better choices, I somewhat feel Samius, wSpyro, CAV, and maybe Baro & Sess would do rather well at the job. -----
---
Once in my dreams, I rose and soared. No matter how I'm knocked around or beaten down, I will stand up restored. |
Edited 2 times - Last edited at 03:51:22 17/08/2014 by Seiki
|
Trix Master 100
Diamond Sparx
![]() |
#40 Posted: 23:56:57 16/08/2014
Quote: LegoLander
That's a chick, not a cock. Quote: cowpowa23
Well except the Spyro D is inactive and Gillgrunt is not really doing a good job, but you know at least he does little bit. I mean I respect military choices and what not on Spyro D's end, but should have quit the mod-job. Because you can be selected for missions and other military stuff, that would take up internet time. I have vented about the mods before. I'm done wasting my breath and repeating myself over. It's exhausting typing vents you know.
---
If you cannot handle me at my pumpkin spiciest, you do not deserve me at my pumpkin sweetest icon from Empoh |
LegoLander
Yellow Sparx
![]() |
#41 Posted: 00:03:09 17/08/2014
Quote: Trix Master 100
Psssssh, technicalities.
---
The person who finally changed his Christmas avatar. Give me a cookie. |
somePerson
Diamond Sparx
![]() |
#42 Posted: 00:25:01 17/08/2014
Remember when people were pissed off about Aura not being a mod? Tbh I think a mod needs to be an all around listener and go trough most topics matter how long it is. (Bar topic) I also want a mod who will moderate their section and not others. Mods also need to be honest because you need to really teach users lessons and not tell them the while truth while being clear at the same time. But most importantly I need a mod who is neutral because being biased to users can get you to be taken advantage of.
But what do I know? I'm an idiot after all. |
Ninpire
Gold Sparx
![]() |
#43 Posted: 01:59:40 17/08/2014
Guys I should totally be a mod promote me
|
CAV
Platinum Sparx
![]() |
#44 Posted: 02:42:10 17/08/2014
Also going to throw out there the occasional hypocrisy of some of the mods when handling problems. Along with potential bias like some people here have mentioned, there's also been a time or two where I see a mod talk about somebody handling a problem or resolving a conflict, but then refusing to do so themselves at another time.
And yes JCW takes jokes too seriously sometimes but he's still among the best. Quote: Sesshomaru75
Maybe when she suggested the idea of choosing her successor Dark was like "oh hell no". Quote: zer0dch
Believe me when I say that this site is a lot better than some others, including those who have better mod teams. I think Gillgrunt was 11-12 when he was picked, and he was just barely a Green sparx. No offense to him (he seems like a decent guy and I haven't seen him do anything bad as a mod) but there is absolutely no way in hell you should be chosen as a mod when you're that young both figuratively and literally. I know I made a joke earlier about him throwing darts at the wall, but it really does often look and feel like Dark saw the 100+ applications given to him, and chose at random. Partly to get the process over with (it was clear he didn't want to hire mods but was forced to) and partly to be unpredictable and throw everybody for a loop when all of the popular choices weren't picked (save for maybe two). |
Edited 2 times - Last edited at 02:47:45 17/08/2014 by CAV
|
Please login or register a forum account to post a message.