darkSpyro

I tried Funny Bone on both paths, C-Tier for Tail Wagger, F-Tier for Bone Zoner

Overview: His first attack(bone disc) is decent, it goes through enemies and it does decent damage, but it's a little slow. His secondary attack(bone saw), it's a little hard to explain, so I'll explain later when talking about his paths. His third attack(bone paw) just plain sucks because it takes FOREVER to conjure but it dies INSTANTLY. The soul gem makes this SLIGHTLY usable, but it is still not a good attack. He also just feels slow.

Bone Zoner: The ability for the discs to explode really doesn't help and the play catch upgrade is too gimmicky and doesn't work well, but I guess its something. His bone saw attack is crap on this path and it what makes this path make him feel really unbalanced and boring. His ONLY saving grace is that his disc damage is decent.

Tail Wagger: Giving him that extra level of charge is a pretty good boost. His head case upgrade is what really shines and it can really destroy larger enemies if your position is right. The upgrades in this path really balance him out and make him usable. The bone paw upgrade is pretty useless, because the bone paw is crappy like I mentioned earlier, and the way you have to position yourself is AWKWARD. Overall, it is a VAST improvement over the other path.

I liked his Bone Zoner but I see it's flaws.

Quote: GigaCamo

I liked his Bone Zoner but I see it's flaws.

Better than Tail Wagger?

I liked the fetch gimmick and I felt his healing power felt quick and recovers HP quickly.

Quote: GigaCamo

I liked the fetch gimmick and I felt his healing power felt quick and recovers HP quickly.

Yeah, I guess I see your point, but like I mentioned earlier, the paw is useless due to a slow setup time and fraility. And the fetch gimmick, I agree, but I wish you could manually chase after the disc, but thats just me.

I agree with E-Knight on Funny Bone. He wasn't as fun to play as I thought he was. Hopefully Bat Spin will be better.

Quote: ExcitonKnight

Quote: GigaCamo

I liked the fetch gimmick and I felt his healing power felt quick and recovers HP quickly.

Yeah, I guess I see your point, but like I mentioned earlier, the paw is useless due to a slow setup time and fraility. And the fetch gimmick, I agree, but I wish you could manually chase after the disc, but thats just me.

I see his ups and downs and manually controlling would stop me from missing enemies.

Quote: GigaCamo

Quote: ExcitonKnight

Quote: GigaCamo

I liked the fetch gimmick and I felt his healing power felt quick and recovers HP quickly.

Yeah, I guess I see your point, but like I mentioned earlier, the paw is useless due to a slow setup time and fraility. And the fetch gimmick, I agree, but I wish you could manually chase after the disc, but thats just me.

I see his ups and downs and manually controlling would stop me from missing enemies.

Exactly!

I often crash into walls anyways, I'm gonna try Dune Bug because I remember him being bad.

I might not do any more of the tests until after Christmas, just so you know. Hoping to have Light/Dark by then.

I was going to to have the list not open on Christmas through the rest of 2014. Christmas Eve will be the final day in 2014.

Wait, does that mean this will be over after Christmas, or that there'll just be a new list in 2015?

PLEASE DON'T TELL ME THIS WILL COME TO AN END

No. It's just that this topic will be inactive 12/24/14 - 12/31/14 and zero content will be added. I will start updating 1/1/15 on this topic. It will be open forever but I just want a holiday break. You don't have to worry.

^Okay, I'm glad I don't have to worry

Oh, okay, I getcha now.

Sorry for scaring you two but i should have worded it better.

Hopefully after Christmas more people will help out with this thing.

Quote: AdamGregory03

Hopefully after Christmas more people will help out with this thing.

Agreed, I swear I thought it was only you,me, and GC

3 people are better than 1 and I agree we need more people onboard this list.

Well, after completing the main story, I'll try and help. But, this would be my first time doing anything like this. What do you do? Just run around and beat the **** out of enemies?

Quote: mega spyro

Well, after completing the main story, I'll try and help. But, this would be my first time doing anything like this. What do you do? Just run around and beat the **** out of enemies?

Basically. I like to do it on A Fight to Remember, but that's just me.

Quote: AdamGregory03

Quote: mega spyro

Well, after completing the main story, I'll try and help. But, this would be my first time doing anything like this. What do you do? Just run around and beat the **** out of enemies?

Basically. I like to do it on A Fight to Remember, but that's just me.

And I usually like to do it on the last level of Kaos Mode

Anyone here got the light and dark characters?

^Not me

I'm was wondering how they did. Anyways, how good is Wind Up- Toy Box

^I have him lvl 20 on the Winder path, and I don't feel like resetting him, so I will try to test Winder tomorrow

Quote: GigaCamo

Anyone here got the light and dark characters?

I got Knight Mare! She's not fully upgraded though. Plus, I know I'm getting the Knight Light pack for Christmas.

Ok. I was trying Cynder- Shadow Dancer and she isn't that good. But I'll also try a Wind Up on Toy Box

Quote: GigaCamo

Ok. I was trying Cynder- Shadow Dancer and she isn't that good. But I'll also try a Wind Up on Toy Box

I could have sworn Cynder was good on that path, which Cynder did you use?

Series 1. She might be really good on that path but I'm not the best Cynder user.

So... has anyone tried out Flameslinger yet? I have a S2 one I can analyze. Provided if that's wanted, of course.

^ I haven't because TBH, Flameslinger is one of my least favorites to play as.

What's TBH?

Quote: AdamGregory03

What's TBH?

To Be Honest

Oh, okay. Well, I'll try him out after Christmas if no one else wants to.

I got High Five! Ill try his Speedy Slammer and record in 2015

I got High Five as well!!! I will be trying out his Pollen Prince path

Not sure if it's too early or not, but I did try out S2 on both paths, plus two villains. Again on A Fight to Remember. All my tests are gonna be on A Fight to Remember. So anyway.

Flameslinger
His arrows have good range, and his Flame Dash is an effective method for getting out of the way of attacks while damaging following enemies. His Volley Shot I also found was somewhat useful, although he stops and stands still while using it, which could leave him vulnerable.

His Series 2 Wow Pow is kind of pointless though. All it does is make him run faster, and the larger flame trails don't even deal more damage.

Pyromancer Path - C Tier
This path isn't totally bad, but it's more reliant on leaving around pits of flames from your attacks. And while the Supernova upgrade it really cool, the Inferno Blast is difficult to aim and his arrows don't deal to much damage on their own.

Marksman Path - A or at least B Tier
With this path, his arrows are much more useful and deal more damage, plus they explode and damage other nearby enemies. He also shoots three at once now, perfect for taking on hordes.

Eye Scream - F Tier
Her attacks deal a PATHETIC amount of damage. The only way I found to use her effectively is to spam the first attack and just have the eyeballs swarm around enemies. As for her second attack, sometimes the bigger eye hurts enemies and sometimes it doesn't.

Luminous - S Tier
Opposite to Eye Scream, Luminous' attacks deal a high amount of damage. In fact, his weakest attack (after evolving) only deals 95 damage. The rotating crystal that fires a beam is really useful, and his falling crystal attack is his most powerful move.

Yeah, I always thought Eye Scream looked really crappy ever since Buuzer showed off all of the Light & Dark villains
EDIT:Also, do you think He/she/it could also belong in G-Tier?

I will try to test the other 3 light villains + Knight Light ASAP since I got Sunscraper Spire for Christmas (I didn't get Midnight Museum, but since I got SSp, I really don't care a whole lot)
I have a feeling that Blaster-tron will be low and Eye Five will be high.

Well so far I know these for sure:

Light
1. S tier for obvious reasons.
2. Eye Five should be B or C tier because he actually does some decent numbers and can go fast when lit up, but not much in versatility and no projectile so not perfectly balanced.
3. Lob Goblin is surprisingly A tier I'd say since his lobs do some nasty damage and his mines actually milk out some good numbers too. He may actually be one of the better trolls I hate to admit.
4. Blaster Tron I haven't gotten yet so I can't say at the moment.

Dark
1. A tier since his stealth is helpful and does hit hard, but his bombs aren't all that helpful. Luminous hits harder anyways.
2. Fisticuffs I say B tier since his punch has very good range and his rocket fist does a lot of damage.
3. Eye Scream yea F tier sounds about right sadly.
4. Tae Kwon Crow don't have but can already say A tier since he slashes fast and deals massive damage with each slice and his stars do a great amount of damage as well.

Happy New Year! Let's start 2015 by adding the light and dark.

OKAY!

Happy New Year!

I hope all of you enjoyed the first day of 2015 (I sure did)

Also all of the Light and Dark characters except for Knight Light, Knight Mare, Spotlight, Blackout and Blastertron have been added.

Blaster-Tron sucks, I expect him to low

I will try him out when I get home tonight.

I bought Bat Spin just out of obligation, and I swear her Bat Transformation path is really good. Just throw out some bats, use the Sonic Screech and you've got a good deal of chip damage and rapid healing options.

Blaster-Tron belongs in C-Tier, I expected him to be worse TBH
His first attack(beams): It's okay I guess. Charging it up can be useful, but it leaves you open and you turn REALLY slowly. It's damage is actually kinda decent, but it has a bit of a recovery time
His second attack(jet dash): Useful for escaping areas where you are surrounded, and it has pretty decent knockback. It goes fast, but the distance is kinda ehh

Sounds fair.