Quote: defpallyBut, Bahumut, I wasn't really directing it towards the impact of the economy, only the negative influence of middle men on the price and their lack of positive benefit. For many reasons oil, like Skylanders do not need middle men in order for their "economy" to function. Every drop of oil could be sold when it rolls into port for market price, and Exxon operates like this (and makes massive profits). Most of the people that buy Skylanders could find them on shelves just fine if scalpers didn't clear new ones out.
Many other commodities, for example crops, do - but that is another story. And just because it can be done does not make it ok/good, and I see a lot of justification for scalping from people that say "if people are willing to pay, why is it wrong?". "If I can leverage a huge mutual fund to drive up the price of oil to make a fortune, why is it wrong?"
In the end, it is mostly about empathy. I don't know people on the forums personally. I don't know what they have bought on Craigslist for a big markup, or bought a football ticket at twice face value. So that may or may not apply, it is hard to use that as an example. But, we all buy gas, and all complain about it. It's easier to say "Hey, gas prices suck don't they? Some fat cat on Wall St. is lighting cigars with hundred dollar bills off that money. Next time you brag about making $1,400 off parents by selling Skylanders remember that karma.". If I say it's ok to take advantage of someone, then they take advantage of someone else, and so on ... where does it end?
That's a good question, Defpally: where does it end? The best answer I can give is that it "ends" when one of two things happens ... either A) demand for the product declines markedly, or B ) the government steps-in and says "enough is enough".
I can certainly understand your disdain for the "middle man", and I am sharply impressed with your level of knowledge, your analysis, and your composure (all the most intellectual Skylanders hunters are in Charlotte, it seems! :-) )
However, putting aside Utopian fantasies, I think you'd have to agree that the "middle man" is a naturally-occurring aspect of the free market capitalistic society we live in. Even if the "middle man" is unnecessary, many consumers are perfectly willing to accept higher prices in exchange for high levels of convenience and customer service. Granted, not ALL consumers are willing to pay more for convenience and customer service ... but MANY are willing.
I guess my beef with your analogy to crude oil prices is that the cigar-smoking "fat cats" that were/are jacking up crude oil prices by speculating on futures in oil ... all or most of those douchebags are already exorbitantly wealthy. And while it's fair to say that greed is one factor (out of many factors, usually) that drives the average scalper ... the scale, as you put it, does matter ... everyday scalpers aren't wealthy fat-cats. This economic system flatly encourages all individuals to seek any potential market and tap it for economic gain. Fortunately, there are laws against prostitution, child labor, human trafficking, distribution of controlled substances, insider stock trading, false advertising, fraud, etc, etc. It's safe to say that the re-sale of collectible toys doesn't come anywhere close to that level of detrimental effect on society ... so, like I said, the scale does matter.