darkSpyro

she did she said that ta me

Oh,but still....it doesnt really matter. If you give her credit then its not illegal or anything to post her comics here.

I repeat:
Posting a page to show what she draw is not the same that posting her whole comic to show it on a forum. You must ask her, not only credit, for this.

If I make a comic and somone post it on a forum, crediting to me but not asking me first, if I not agree then is illegal.

If you already asked for the whole comic, there is no problem

well not ilegal like call the police illegal now that would be harsh

urgh why are shalonesk's fans so protective somtimes

Why only fans?
Who said I'm a fan? Maybe I not like her style.

Quote: GrandSpyro18

well not ilegal like call the police illegal now that would be harsh

If someone post a copyrighted thing withouth permission is as illegal as stealing.

Quote: banderi

Why only fans?
Who said I'm a fan? Maybe I not like her style.

Quote: GrandSpyro18

well not ilegal like call the police illegal now that would be harsh

If someone post a copyrighted thing withouth permission is as illegal as stealing.

I dont think you understand what copyright is.Copyright means you can not use someones created places,characters,etc in your own creations.

Again I say,Its not stealing if you give them credit.To be honest thats more like advertisement becuase more people can see what they do.

Also,Do you know how ShalloneSK feels?They might want this becuase it makes them more known.If you think it is that big of a deal why dont you find a way to e-mail them or something and see what they say?

Quote: crazyspyrofan

Quote: banderi

Why only fans?
Who said I'm a fan? Maybe I not like her style.

Quote: GrandSpyro18

well not ilegal like call the police illegal now that would be harsh

If someone post a copyrighted thing withouth permission is as illegal as stealing.

I dont think you understand what copyright is.Copyright means you can not use someones created places,characters,etc in your own creations.

Again I say,Its not stealing if you give them credit.To be honest thats more like advertisement becuase more people can see what they do.

Also,Do you know how ShalloneSK feels?They might want this becuase it makes them more known.If you think it is that big of a deal why dont you find a way to e-mail them or something and see what they say?

I totally agree with you. It's like people posting pictures up. Did they have permisstion? No they did not.

What pictures are people posting without permission?

I saw a forum that is closed because a writer sue it because someone posted his book (crediting) withouth permission.


Quote: crazyspyrofan

I dont think you understand what copyright is.Copyright means you can not use someones created places,characters,etc in your own creations.

Your post are a your creation for the copyright laws.

You know like in RP's? They post anime pictures that people made adn they didn't have permission for it. But they don't get sued.

Why noone reported them?

Anyway, is obvious that if the owner of the copyright don't sue the illegal posting, if reported, than this appears "like" a permission and the illegal posting is now legal.

Well, they don't say it's their drawing. They just post to what they think thier character looks like. It's not stealing.

Yeah, if you posted one of her comics in a topic and said...

"How do you guys like my art?"

THAT would be stealing.

But since we are giving ShaloneSK all of the credit she deserves it's not stealing.

^Exactly!

I agree with Cuzzberry.

And Banderi, we post offical Spyro artwork on here, but did we ask the owners? The owners of the offical art didn't tell us off for posting it here because non of us has gone 'omg i dreeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeew dis'. And why would it be ilegal to praise art?

Also, if you know my previous 'Art' topic my friends dared me to do it. .

Posting withouth permission is illegal, not stealing.

A forum has surely permission by the owners, and so this website.

from my knowledge, she or he posted a link to some art by shalonSK. and banderi, did you ask permission to use your avatar?

Also, this isn't an official thing. We're just a bunch of fans admiring art, it's not like we're giving it to some company for them to make a movie or a videogame of it.

SpyroxElora. That's what would happen. :D

My avatar is made by me, using free tools.

I'm just saying that post directly a copyrighted mark withouth permission and (if requested) credits is illegal. Before doing anything, ask the autor.
Post a link to a copyrighted mark or thing crediting is not illegal.

I think we can close here this OT.

i wouldn't say illegal

Ok, sueable by the owner of the copyright

well not really sue probably only if the person using it and saying it is his he created and all that crap yeah

Quote: banderi

My avatar is made by me, using free tools.

I'm just saying that post directly a copyrighted mark withouth permission and (if requested) credits is illegal. Before doing anything, ask the autor.
Post a link to a copyrighted mark or thing crediting is not illegal.

I think we can close here this OT.

You are really work with,you know that? Stealing art means you take someones art and post it saying it's yours. Theres nothing about whats illegal or sueing or crap like that. He posted it to give credit for Shalones work, and not saying it's his.

^I agree with the post above.

Quote:

You are really work with,you know that? Stealing art means you take someones art and post it saying it's yours. Theres nothing about whats illegal or sueing or crap like that. He posted it to give credit for Shalones work, and not saying it's his.

THANK YOU thats what i was trying to say i did not steal it, i gave her credit and i did not say it was mine

Quote: GrandSpyro18

Quote:

You are really work with,you know that? Stealing art means you take someones art and post it saying it's yours. Theres nothing about whats illegal or sueing or crap like that. He posted it to give credit for Shalones work, and not saying it's his.

THANK YOU thats what i was trying to say i did not steal it, i gave her credit and i did not say it was mine

Thou art welcome. Lol.

I'm not talking about stealing or credits; crediting get the posting as "not stealing" instead of "with a permission, so not illegal".

Post a copyrighted thing or mark with credits is not stealing but post a copyrighted thing or mark withouth permission is illegal.
If the owner not release permission and don't want someone to post his thing on a public forum, then it is sueable.

Et capì?

Quote: banderi

I'm not talking about stealing or credits; crediting get the posting as "not stealing" instead of "with a permission, so not illegal".

Post a copyrighted thing or mark with credits is not stealing but post a copyrighted thing or mark withouth permission is illegal.
If the owner not release permission and don't want someone to post his thing on a public forum, then it is sueable.

Et capì?

Millions of people do that on forums and possibly this forum. They do not get sued for it also. It is also not illegal, if they are giving CREDIT TO THE ART!

Quote: TheFlyingSeal

Quote: banderi

I'm not talking about stealing or credits; crediting get the posting as "not stealing" instead of "with a permission, so not illegal".

Post a copyrighted thing or mark with credits is not stealing but post a copyrighted thing or mark withouth permission is illegal.
If the owner not release permission and don't want someone to post his thing on a public forum, then it is sueable.

Et capì?

Millions of people do that on forums and possibly this forum. They do not get sued for it also. It is also not illegal, if they are giving CREDIT TO THE ART!

exactly i said on the art credit to shalonesk and pus the link too the art goes straight to her DA page

Quote: banderi

I'm not talking about stealing or credits; crediting get the posting as "not stealing" instead of "with a permission, so not illegal".

Post a copyrighted thing or mark with credits is not stealing but post a copyrighted thing or mark withouth permission is illegal.
If the owner not release permission and don't want someone to post his thing on a public forum, then it is sueable.

Et capì?

It isnt sueable,just like Flying Seal said people post others work and credit them all the time,and they dont get sued.Plus,like I said before,it is more like advertisement.

I'm always talking about copyrighted mark, not single pictures and art.

Then:
1) is only in the USA, because here in Italy are sueable and illegal.
2) the web police is not so efficient.
3) you're not talking about marks.

Quote: banderi

I'm always talking about copyrighted mark, not single pictures and art.

Then:
1) is only in the USA, because here in Italy are sueable and illegal.
2) the web police is not so efficient.
3) you're not talking about marks.

People on Youtube have made videos using clips from copyrighted movies and video games,but they give those companies credit.They dont ask permission and they still dont get sued.

I mean "mark" as an entire copyrighted thing like a whole comic, not just a reference to it like an image.

yeah i just said she did a good job and i do now own it

AND it give's the PAGE it's ON!

Just 1 page, not all of them
This is absolutely legal (with credits)

yyyyyyyyyyyyyyeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeppp

I think if Spyro and Cynder had a kid they should drown it.

Ok, I don`t really mind the conversation about the comics and everything, but I think we are sort of getting off topic.

heh srry i agree

Infatti.. Yeah
Quote: banderi

I think we can close here this OT.

It`s ok. It happens

that would be cool if after DotD the people actually had cynder and spyros kids in the next game like the official game maybe spyro and cynder would have to save them or somethin

Heh
Somebody said, that LoS is prequel to StD, and StD Spyro is son of LoS Spyro. Well...
Maybe in YotD little StD Spyro is saving his brothers and sisters? Imagine Spyro and Cynder having 100 eggs... Busy nights (was it 100 eggs or more?)

Spyro and Cynder are obviously the oddly compatible couple. They should be together, HOWEVER, as some have said if they WERE to have a kid, it would probably signal the series' downfall. Spyro and Cynder having a kid would add another character, much younger, making their adventures more difficult and complicated.

Don't get me wrong, it would be interesting (in a good way) to see a kid in the picture, everyone knows Spyro and Cynder are gonna get together, its obvious they love each other.

I just find it really strange that Spyro would have a partner like Cynder.

Spyro and Cynder having a kid?
They need some luurve music!

Eww, wouldn't Spyro think that's disgusting to do that type of thing anyway, I really can't imagine him doing that type of thing, lol.

Hah, Spyro's a guy! And guys will be guys, Super!
Ehhh lets skip to the kid part, please?
I don't think they should have a child of SxC in a Spyro game, They'd have to be adults, and Spyro's just not an adult :/
It is fun fan-fiction/art material though :3